Check out our current Cookie Gram - You don't want to miss it! See now
 

SUGAR YOUR INBOX!

be the first to hear about new products and specials

Custom Designs

Custom cookies means you are able to create personalized cookies that are unique and follow the theme of your event or celebration.

cookies for every occasion

Celebrations

Send your guests home with a cookie favor! From 1st birthdays, to showers and weddings, Jersey Cookie Girl can create a favor for you!

Learn More

Gift Them

Looking for a thank-you gift, housewarming, congratulations, or "just because" gift? Send them a cookie platter they won't forget!

Learn More

In Stores

Now available in many stores! Find out where you can get your Jersey Cookie Girl cookie fix any time you like!

Find Locations

Why Jersey Cookie Girl?

See what our valued customers have to say…

Big hit at the party!

I ordered cookies for my son’s 3rd birthday party..They were PJ masks characters..Nicole did an amazing job on them.. all the kids loved them including the parents.. not to mention they were delicious.. They were such a hit at the party. I will definitely be ordering from her again thanks so much 😊

Jessica on Google

5.0
2018-05-25T01:01:48-04:00

Jessica on Google

I ordered cookies for my son’s 3rd birthday party..They were PJ masks characters..Nicole did an amazing job on them.. all the kids loved them including the parents.. not to mention they were delicious.. They were such a hit at the party. I will definitely be ordering from her again thanks so much 😊

Beautiful and Delicious

I couldn't ask for a better experience! Nicole is prompt in responding to inquiries. She listened to my request and went above and beyond to make my vision for my 4 year old's cookie platter come to life! The cookies are beautiful and delicious, too. Will be visiting again!

Christina on Google

5.0
2018-05-25T01:02:27-04:00

Christina on Google

I couldn't ask for a better experience! Nicole is prompt in responding to inquiries. She listened to my request and went above and beyond to make my vision for my 4 year old's cookie platter come to life! The cookies are beautiful and delicious, too. Will be visiting again!

A staple at family functions

For over 6 years we have had cookies made by the Jersey Cookie Girl for almost every special occasion! From birthdays to baptisms to holiday parties, the cookies baked by the Jersey Cookie Girl have become a staple at our family functions. The cookies are always a work of art and tasty too! They are always fresh and well packaged. The owner is terrific and very professional.

Debora on Google

5.0
2018-05-25T00:58:14-04:00

Debora on Google

For over 6 years we have had cookies made by the Jersey Cookie Girl for almost every special occasion! From birthdays to baptisms to holiday parties, the cookies baked by the Jersey Cookie Girl have become a staple at our family functions. The cookies are always a work of art and tasty too! They are always fresh and well packaged. The owner is terrific and very professional.

Taste as good as they look

I ordered cookies multiple times and they were amazing! Colors were perfect, everyone who had them enjoyed them so much and said that they tasted as good as they look. Jersey Cookie Girl does an amazing job creating cookies!! Would recommend for all occasions!

Mike on Google

5.0
2018-05-25T00:58:43-04:00

Mike on Google

I ordered cookies multiple times and they were amazing! Colors were perfect, everyone who had them enjoyed them so much and said that they tasted as good as they look. Jersey Cookie Girl does an amazing job creating cookies!! Would recommend for all occasions!

Exceeded Expectations!

I am so happy that I stumbled along Nicole and Jersey Girl cookies. I couldn’t be more pleased with the service and quality. I last minute called on Monday for an order of 3 dozen tooth shaped cookies for my assistants, she told me no problem and had them ready by Thursday at 2. When I called to ask if I can come earlier she was so accommodating, and pleasant, She even offered to bring them out to the car so that we wouldn’t slip and fall from the snow. I am impressed, even with the snow storm and parts...

Christine on Google

5.0
2018-05-25T00:59:31-04:00

Christine on Google

I am so happy that I stumbled along Nicole and Jersey Girl cookies. I couldn’t be more pleased with the service and quality. I last minute called on Monday for an order of 3 dozen tooth shaped cookies for my assistants, she told me no problem and had them ready by Thursday at 2. When I called to ask if I can come earlier she was so accommodating, and pleasant, She even offered to bring them out to the car so that we wouldn’t slip and fall from the snow. I am impressed, even with the snow storm and parts of my town losing power she still was prompt and friendly. The cookies?! THEY EXCEEDED EXPECTATION! Not only did they look amazing, they taste PHENOMENAL! Thank you thank you thank you!!! We’ll def bsee ordering more cookies for other office events.
5
5